In 91302, insurers declined 10.2% of homeowners renewals in 2023 and 12.0% of insured homes were on the FAIR Plan in 2022, against 9.4% and 3.2% statewide. I shop admitted carriers first, then surplus lines, then the FAIR Plan with a DIC policy and any excess layer, bound together with one set of dates.
What the numbers say about 91302
Of the homeowners policies in 91302 that came up for renewal in 2023, insurers declined 10.2% (625 of 6,112), against 9.4% statewide. In 2022, 12.0% of insured homes in 91302 were on the California FAIR Plan (831 of 6,931), against 3.2% statewide. Those are California Department of Insurance figures, by ZIP code, and they describe Calabasas better than any carrier's appetite guide does.
The year-by-year non-renewal shares for 91302: 2020: 15.0%, 2021: 14.6%, 2022: 11.7%, 2023: 10.2%. The ZIP lookup on this site shows the same figures for any California address.
Why Calabasas is hard to insure
Calabasas is an incorporated city served by the Los Angeles County Fire Department from Station 68 on Calabasas Road, not LAFD (the 91302 ZIP also takes in Hidden Hills), and most of it is mapped in the Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone under the County's fuel modification and brush clearance rules. The housing is newer than the Hollywood Hills and much of it is in gated communities with HOAs, Calabasas Park, The Oaks, Mountain View Estates, where the association's master policy covers common areas and the owner's policy covers the house, and where the dwelling limit, the HOA's requirements and the lender's requirements all have to agree. Newer construction with ember-resistant features is the reason Calabasas still has admitted options that Topanga, next door, mostly does not.
The Woolsey Fire in November 2018 burned 96,949 acres from Simi Valley to the ocean through the hills around Calabasas, destroyed 1,643 structures and killed three people; the whole city was under mandatory evacuation by November 11 and homes were lost on its edges. Carriers reset their appetite for 91302 after it, and 91302 was on the 2025 moratorium list for the Palisades Fire.
How a Calabasas home gets insured
Three ways a home here gets insured, in the order I try them:
- Admitted carriers. Still writing for some homes: newer construction, ember-resistant vents and roofing, cleared defensible space, a clean loss history. Appetite is limited and changes street by street.
- Surplus lines. For homes the admitted market declines. Not backed by the state's guaranty association (CIGA), a point I put in writing with the fee disclosure before anything is bound.
- FAIR Plan plus a DIC policy. The FAIR Plan covers fire or lightning, internal explosion and smoke, up to three million in dwelling coverage for a residential property. A difference-in-conditions policy adds liability, theft, water damage and additional living expenses. Above three million, an excess layer sits on top. The three policies need one set of dates and matching limits, which is the broker's job; the FAIR Plan sells none of the other two.
Before you accept the FAIR Plan quote
Two things to check before accepting a FAIR Plan quote. After a declared wildfire emergency the Insurance Commissioner can order a moratorium on cancellations and non-renewals for ZIP codes in or next to the fire perimeter, under Insurance Code section 675.1. Bulletin 2025-1, issued January 9, 2025 and amended on January 17, covered every ZIP code on this page for one year from the January 7, 2025 emergency declaration; that year ended on January 7, 2026, so a notice received now stands unless a new order names your ZIP. AB 2038, signed in September 2026, makes future moratoriums two years long from January 1, 2027. The Department of Insurance keeps the list of orders and ZIPs. And California's Safer from Wildfires standard, in force since the 2022 regulation, requires carriers that rate on wildfire risk to give discounts for ember-resistant vents, a Class A roof, a five-foot ember-resistant zone, cleared defensible space and the other listed measures, so a home that was declined two years ago may qualify again after the work is done.
Trusts, LLCs and lenders
Many homes here are held in a trust or an LLC. The named insured has to match the title holder, the trust or company is added where the carrier allows it, and the lender's mortgagee clause has to read exactly as the loan documents require, or the evidence of insurance bounces at escrow. I handle that with the escrow officer directly.
What I need to quote
The address, year built and square footage, roof type and year, updates to wiring, plumbing and heating, how the title is held, the current declarations page if there is one, and the date coverage must start. A declarations page and a renewal or non-renewal notice are enough to begin; the rest I can pull from public records and ask about as I go.
Common questions
My HOA requires certain coverage. Does that change the policy?
It can. Associations often require minimum dwelling limits or specific endorsements, and a FAIR Plan plus DIC stack has to be documented to the HOA the same way an admitted policy would be. I read the CC&Rs' insurance section before binding.
Is a FAIR Plan policy enough for my lender?
Usually, for the hazard requirement, when the dwelling limit meets the loan's requirement. The DIC policy is for you: liability, theft, water damage and living expenses are not the lender's concern, but they are yours.
My rebuild cost is more than the FAIR Plan limit. Can the home still be covered?
Yes. The FAIR Plan limit applies to its dwelling coverage; an excess policy covers the rebuild cost above it, coordinated with the DIC policy so the three documents describe one house.
Can I buy the DIC policy from the FAIR Plan?
No. The FAIR Plan writes only its own policy. A difference-in-conditions policy comes from a separate admitted or surplus lines insurer, through a broker.
General information about home insurance in Calabasas as of October 2026, not legal advice. Department of Insurance figures are by ZIP code (91302) for 2020–2023 and FAIR Plan 2022; carrier appetite, moratorium orders and fire hazard maps change. Check your parcel's zone with the fire agency named above. Coverage depends on underwriting and the terms, conditions and exclusions of the policy actually issued.