Claims and billing
Insurance company claims numbers and payment pages.
The claims line, online claim page and payment page for 67 insurance companies we place coverage with, in one place. Most take claims 24/7. If anyone is hurt or in danger, call 911 first.
Your policy documents come first. Your declarations page, ID card or bill shows the exact claims and billing contacts for your policy, and some programs use a different number than the company’s main line. Not sure which company insures you? Get it by email, sent only to the email on your file.
| Insurance company | Report a claim | Pay or billing | Customer service | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aegis GeneralObsidian Pacific Insurance Co. (Aegis General), Obsidian Pacific Insurance Co., Aegis, Aegis General Insurance Agency, Aegis First | (844) 631-7819 | Pay online | (844) 207-4339 | Source |
| AhoyAhoy!, Ahoy! Insurance, Ahoy MIT | (855) 611-2469 · File online | Pay online · (855) 289-2469 | (855) 289-2469 | Source |
| American Modern Insurance GroupAmerican Modern, American Modern Home, American Modern Home Insurance Company, American Family Home Insurance Company, American Modern Selec | (800) 375-2075 · File online | Pay online · (800) 543-2644 | (800) 543-2644 | Source |
| AmTrust FinancialAmTrust, Wesco, Wesco Insurance Company, Technology Insurance Company, AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. | (844) 451-0750 · File online | Pay online · (877) 528-7878 | (877) 528-7878 | Source |
| Assurity LifeAssurity, Assurity Life Insurance Company, Assurity Life Insurance Company of New York | (800) 869-0355 · File online | Pay online · (800) 869-0355 | (800) 869-0355 | Source |
| AttuneAttune Insurance, Attune Insurance Services, Inc., Attune Insurance Services LLC | File online | Pay online | (888) 530-4650 | Source |
| Bamboo InsuranceBamboo, Bamboo Insurance Services, Bamboo Ide8 Insurance Services | (877) 333-6938 · File online | Pay online | (833) 922-6266 | Source |
| Berkshire Hathaway GUARDGUARD, Guard Insurance, Berkshire Hathaway GUARD Insurance Companies, AmGUARD Insurance Company, AZGUARD Insurance Company, EastGUARD Insura | (888) 639-2567 · File online | Pay online · (800) 673-2465 | (800) 673-2465 | Source |
| biBERKbiBERK Insurance Services, Wellfleet Insurance Company, Wellfleet New York Insurance Company, National Liability & Fire Insurance Company | (844) 472-0966 · File online | Pay online | (844) 472-0967 | Source |
| Bristol WestBristol West Insurance, Bristol West Insurance Group, Bristol West Insurance Company, Bristol West Casualty Insurance Company | (800) 274-7865 · File online | Pay online · (888) 888-0080 | (888) 888-0080 | Source |
| BriteCoBriteCo Jewelry Insurance, Brite Co | (312) 809-9100 · File online | See your bill | (312) 809-9100 | Source |
| California FAIR PlanCA FAIR Plan, California FAIR Plan Association | (800) 339-4099 · File online | Pay online | Source | |
| Canopius USCanopius, Canopius US Insurance, Inc., Canopius Underwriting Agency, Canopius Lloyd's Syndicate 4444 | File online | See your bill | (630) 994-5600 | Source |
| CerityCerity Insurance | (844) 423-7489 · File online | See your bill | (844) 423-7489 | Source |
| ChubbChubb Commercial, Chubb Small Business, Federal Insurance Company, Westchester, Westchester Fire Insurance Company, ACE American Insurance C | (800) 252-4670 · File online | Pay online · (833) 550-9660 | (866) 972-2727 | Source |
| ClearcoverClearcover Insurance, Clearcover Insurance Company | File online | See your bill | (855) 444-1875 | Source |
| CNACNA Insurance, Continental Casualty Company, Valley Forge Insurance Company, Transportation Insurance Company, National Fire Insurance Compa | (877) 262-2727 · File online | Pay online · (877) 276-7507 | (800) 262-2000 | Source |
| CoterieCoterie Insurance, Coterie Applications Inc. | (855) 680-2440 · File online | Pay online | (855) 566-1011 | Source |
| Cowbell CyberCowbell, Cowbell Insurance, Cowbell Cyber Insurance | (833) 633-8666 · File online | Pay online · (833) 633-8666 | (833) 633-8666 | Source |
| DairylandDairyland Insurance, Dairyland Insurance Company, Viking Insurance | (800) 334-0090 · File online | Pay online · (800) 334-0090 | (800) 334-0090 | Source |
| EmployersEmployers Compensation Insurance Company | (888) 682-6671 · File online | Pay online · (888) 682-6671 | (888) 682-6671 | Source |
| Fetch Pet InsuranceFetch, Fetch by The Dodo, Fetch Pet | File online | Pay online · (866) 467-3875 | (866) 467-3875 | Source |
| First InsuranceFirst Insurance & Risk Management, First Insurance and Risk Management, My First Insurance | File online | See your bill | (866) 205-2114 | Source |
| Foremost InsuranceForemost, Foremost Choice, Foremost Signature, Foremost Insurance Group, Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan, Foremost Propert | (800) 527-3907 · File online | Pay online · (800) 532-4221 | (800) 527-3905 | Source |
| GeoVeraGeoVera Insurance Company, GeoVera Specialty Insurance Company, GeoVera Advantage Insurance Services, Coastal Select Insurance Company | (800) 735-8086 · File online | Pay online | (800) 324-6020 | Source |
| Great American Insurance GroupGreat American, Great American Insurance Company | (844) 424-4669 · File online | Pay online | (800) 545-4269 | Source |
| HagertyHagerty Insurance, Hagerty Insurance Agency, Hagerty Marine, Hagerty Private Client | (800) 385-0274 · File online | Pay online | (877) 922-9701 | Source |
| Hamilton Insurance GroupHamilton Select, Hamilton Select Insurance, Hamilton Specialty, Hamilton | File online | See your bill | Source | |
| The HartfordHartford, Hartford Fire Insurance Company, Hartford Casualty Insurance Company, Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company, Hartford Insurance | (800) 327-3636 · File online | Pay online | (866) 467-8730 | Source |
| HiscoxHiscox Insurance Company Inc., Hiscox Inc., HICI | (866) 424-8508 · File online | (866) 283-7545 | (866) 283-7545 | Source |
| ICATICAT Managers, LLC | (800) 754-6919 · File online | Pay online | Source | |
| ICW GroupInsurance Company of the West, Explorer Insurance, Explorer Insurance Company | (877) 442-9669 · File online | Pay online · (888) 339-0843 | (844) 442-9252 | Source |
| Jewelers MutualJewelers Mutual Group, Jewelers Mutual Insurance | (888) 884-2424 · File online | Pay online | (888) 884-2424 | Source |
| KemperKemper Auto, Infinity, Infinity Insurance, Infinity (a Kemper Company), Kemper Personal Insurance, Kemper Direct | (800) 353-6737 · File online | Pay online | (800) 782-1020 | Source |
| Kinsale InsuranceKinsale, Kinsale Insurance Company, Kinsale Capital Group, Aspera, Aspera Insurance Services | (804) 289-1394 · File online | See your bill | (804) 289-1300 | Source |
| LemonadeLemonade Insurance, Lemonade Insurance Company | (844) 733-8666 · File online | See your bill | (844) 733-8666 | Source |
| Liberty MutualLiberty Mutual Insurance, Liberty Mutual Insurance Group | (800) 225-2467 · File online | Pay online · (800) 824-7317 | (800) 290-8711 | Source |
| MarkelMarkel Insurance Company, Evanston Insurance Company, Markel Specialty, Markel American Insurance Company | (800) 362-7535 · File online | Pay online | (800) 446-6671 | Source |
| Mercury InsuranceMercury, Mercury Casualty, Mercury Casualty Company, California Automobile Insurance Company, Mercury Insurance Group | (800) 503-3724 · File online | Pay online · (800) 503-3724 | (800) 503-3724 | Source |
| MonolineMonoline Umbrella, Monoline Insurance Services | (612) 470-1328 · File online | See your bill | (612) 470-1328 | Source |
| MSI (Millennial Specialty Insurance)MSI, MSI MGA, Millennial Specialty Insurance, Millennial Specialty Insurance LLC | (844) 788-0873 · File online | Pay online · (844) 788-0873 | (844) 788-0873 | Source |
| National GeneralNational General Insurance, Integon, Allstate National General, National General, an Allstate company, NatGen | (800) 468-3466 · File online | Pay online | (888) 293-5108 | Source |
| NationwideNationwide Insurance, Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company | (800) 421-3535 · File online | Pay online · (800) 543-3747 | (877) 669-6877 | Source |
| Neptune FloodNeptune Flood Incorporated, Neptune Flood Insurance Services | (727) 202-4815 · File online | Pay online | (727) 202-4815 | Source |
| NEXT InsuranceNext, ERGO NEXT, ERGO NEXT Insurance, Next Insurance US Company, Next Insurance, Inc. | (855) 222-5919 · File online | Pay online | (855) 222-5919 | Source |
| OpenlyOpenly LLC, Openly Insurance | (888) 808-4842 · File online | (888) 808-4842 | (888) 808-4842 | Source |
| Pacific Specialty Insurance CompanyPacific Specialty, PSIC, Pacific Specialty Insurance Co. | (800) 962-1172 · File online | Pay online | (800) 303-5000 | Source |
| Palomar SpecialtyPalomar, Palomar Specialty Insurance Company | (844) 560-7401 · File online | Pay online | (619) 567-5290 | Source |
| Philadelphia Insurance CompaniesPHLY, Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company | (800) 765-9749 · File online | Pay online · (877) 438-7459 | (877) 438-7459 | Source |
| Pie InsurancePie | (844) 581-0828 · File online | Pay online | (855) 705-2716 | Source |
| Progressive CommercialProgressive | (800) 776-4737 · File online | Pay online · (800) 444-4487 | (800) 444-4487 | Source |
| RainbowRainbow Insurance, Rainbow MGA, Rainbow MGA Insurance Agency, userainbow | (888) 727-2462 · File online | (888) 727-2462 | (888) 727-2462 | Source |
| Republic IndemnityRepublic Indemnity Company of America, Republic Indemnity Company of California | (888) 336-7569 · File online | Pay online · (800) 821-4520 | (818) 990-9860 | Source |
| RLIRLI Insurance Company, RLI Corp, Mt. Hawley, Mt. Hawley Insurance Company, Contractors Bonding and Insurance Company | (800) 444-0406 · File online | Pay online · (866) 216-8009 | (800) 331-4929 | Source |
| SafecoSafeco Insurance, Safeco Insurance Company of America | (800) 225-2467 · File online | Pay online · (800) 824-7317 | (800) 290-8711 | Source |
| Simply BusinessSimply Business US, SimplyBusiness | File online | Pay online · (855) 869-5183 | (855) 869-5183 | Source |
| Society InsuranceSociety Insurance, a mutual company | (888) 576-2438 · File online | Pay online · (888) 576-2438 | (888) 576-2438 | Source |
| State Compensation Insurance FundState Fund, SCIF | (888) 782-8338 · File online | Pay online · (888) 782-8338 | (888) 782-8338 | Source |
| SteadilySteadily Insurance, Steadily Insurance Agency, Steadily Insurance Company | (888) 966-1611 · File online | Pay online | (888) 966-1611 | Source |
| SwyfftSwyfft LLC, Swyfft Insurance, Swyfft Homeowners | (877) 799-3389 · File online | Pay online · (855) 479-9338 | (855) 479-9338 | Source |
| ThimbleThimble Insurance, Verifly | (332) 208-8159 · File online | Pay online | Source | |
| THREE by Berkshire HathawayTHREE, THREE Insurance | (800) 507-4495 · File online | Pay online · (800) 507-4495 | (800) 507-4495 | Source |
| TravelersTravelers Insurance, The Travelers Indemnity Company, Travelers Property Casualty Company of America, The Charter Oak Fire Insurance Company | (800) 238-6225 · File online | Pay online · (800) 252-2268 | Source | |
| USLIUnited States Liability Insurance Company, United States Liability Insurance Group, Mount Vernon Fire Insurance Company, U.S. Underwriters I | (888) 523-5545 · File online | Pay online · (866) 632-2003 | (888) 523-5545 | Source |
| Utica NationalUtica, Utica Mutual, Utica Mutual Insurance Company, Utica National Insurance Group | (800) 216-1420 · File online | Pay online · (800) 598-8422 | (800) 598-8422 | Source |
| Wright FloodWright National Flood Insurance Company, Wright Flood Insurance Company, Fidelity National Indemnity Insurance Company | (800) 725-9472 · File online | Pay online | (800) 820-3242 | Source |
| Zenith InsuranceZenith National, Zenith Insurance Company, ZNAT Insurance Company, TheZenith | (800) 440-5020 · File online | Pay online · (800) 440-5020 | (800) 440-5020 | Source |
Numbers and links were taken from each company’s own website (last checked 2026-10-10) and change over time. Company names are trademarks of their owners; listing them doesn’t imply endorsement. Reporting a claim to your insurance company is separate from telling me; please do both, so I can help.
Not shopping yet?
Get a reminder before your renewal.
Tell me when your policy renews and I’ll email you about six weeks before, when it’s worth comparing. One email, no calls.