Homeowners
- State Farm Group · 23.6%
- Allstate Insurance Group · 10.1%
- Erie Insurance Group · 7.8%
- Indiana Farm Bureau Group · 7.5%
- American Family Insurance Group · 7.4%
Directory · Indiana · Updated 2026-10-18
Insurance companies licensed in Indiana
Every property and casualty insurer admitted in Indiana and every eligible surplus lines insurer, with NAIC numbers, the lines each is licensed for, who writes the most of each line, and the market of last resort when nobody else will.
Indiana's regulator doesn't publish a company list that can be read by machine (or it's behind a CAPTCHA or terms that bar automated use), so this page shows what public sources do say: 222 sureties licensed in Indiana per the U.S. Treasury, 62 insurers domiciled here, the state's markets of last resort, and each company's standing in the states that do publish lists.
By Sam Alishahi, independent insurance broker · All states
The market
Who can insure you in Indiana
0licensed (admitted) property and casualty insurers known from other states' lists and Treasury data
0eligible surplus lines insurers for hard-to-place risks
222Treasury-certified sureties licensed here
62insurers domiciled in Indiana
Bonds
Treasury-certified sureties licensed in Indiana
Companies on the U.S. Treasury's Circular 570 (acceptable sureties on federal bonds) that list a Indiana license, with each one's federal underwriting limit.
Companies
Insurers domiciled in Indiana
62 property and casualty insurers have their home office in Indiana. Each company page shows where it is admitted or eligible for surplus lines among the states whose lists are loaded.
| Company | NAIC | Home state | Admitted in | Surplus lines in | Lines |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACE Insurance Company of the Midwest | 26417 | IN | 1 | 0 | Personal auto, Homeowners, Inland marine +1 more |
| Agri Ins Exch Rrg | 28380 | IN | 1 | 0 | General liability |
| American Agricultural Insurance Company DBA: AmericanAg | 10103 | IN | 26 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Crime (burglary and theft) +10 more |
| American Economy Insurance Company | 19690 | IN | 33 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +15 more |
| American Inter-Fidelity Exchange | 40088 | IN | 16 | 2 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, Inland marine +4 more |
| American States Insurance Company | 19704 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +15 more |
| American States Preferred Insurance Company | 37214 | IN | 26 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +12 more |
| American Strategic Insurance Corp | — | IN | 1 | 0 | — |
| American Strategic Insurance Corporation | 10872 | IN | 30 | 0 | Personal auto, Farm and crop, Flood +6 more |
| American Surety Company | 31380 | IN | 35 | 0 | Personal auto, Fidelity bonds, General liability +2 more |
| Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. (a Mutual Company) | 28207 | IN | 20 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Fidelity bonds +8 more |
| Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company | 13528 | IN | 35 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +13 more |
| CGB Insurance Company | 11445 | IN | 4 | 0 | — |
| Chubb National Insurance Company | 10052 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +14 more |
| Clear Spring American Insurance Company | 11219 | IN | 5 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Crime (burglary and theft) +6 more |
| Clear Spring Casualty Insurance Company | 11703 | IN | 5 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Crime (burglary and theft) +6 more |
| Clear Spring National Insurance Company | 12274 | IN | 5 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Crime (burglary and theft) +6 more |
| Clear Spring Property and Casualty Company | 15563 | IN | 34 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +13 more |
| Community Blood Centers' Exchange, Risk Retention Group | 13893 | IN | 7 | 0 | General liability, Medical malpractice, Professional liability (E&O) |
| Consolidated Insurance Company | 22640 | IN | 7 | 0 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, Commercial package (BOP, CMP) +2 more |
| CSAA FIRE \u0026 CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY | 10921 | IN | 16 | 0 | Personal auto, Homeowners, General liability +3 more |
| CSAA General Insurance Company | 37770 | IN | 18 | 0 | Personal auto, Earthquake, Flood +7 more |
| Diamond State Insurance Company | 42048 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +16 more |
| Federal Insurance Company | 20281 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +18 more |
| Grain Dealers Mutual Insurance Company | 22098 | IN | 23 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial package (BOP, CMP) +10 more |
| Great Northern Insurance Company | 20303 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +17 more |
| Hartford Casualty Insurance Company | 29424 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +17 more |
| Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest | 37478 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +17 more |
| Indiana Farmers Indemnity Insurance Company | 17478 | IN | 4 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +5 more |
| Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company | 22624 | IN | 4 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +9 more |
| Indiana Insurance Company | 22659 | IN | 9 | 0 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, Commercial package (BOP, CMP) +12 more |
| Infinity Indemnity Insurance Company | 10061 | IN | 3 | 0 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, General liability |
| Infinity Insurance Company | 22268 | IN | 31 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +10 more |
| Infinity Select Insurance Company | 20260 | IN | 7 | 0 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, General liability +1 more |
| Infinity Standard Insurance Company | 12599 | IN | 11 | 0 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, Crime (burglary and theft) +8 more |
| LM Property and Casualty Insurance Company | 32352 | IN | 29 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +15 more |
| Medical Protective Company (The) | 11843 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +14 more |
| Meridian Security Insurance Company | 23353 | IN | 28 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Crime (burglary and theft) +10 more |
| Midwestern Equity Title Insurance Company | 10282 | IN | 1 | 0 | — |
| Monroe Guaranty Insurance Company | 32506 | IN | 23 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +12 more |
| NAMIC Insurance Company, Inc. | 29629 | IN | 3 | 6 | General liability |
| National Direct Insurance Company | 12230 | IN | 1 | 0 | General liability |
| National Insurance Association, The National Corporation A/I/F | 27944 | IN | 17 | 0 | Personal auto, General liability, Commercial property (fire and allied lines) +1 more |
| National Trust Insurance Company | 20141 | IN | 23 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +12 more |
| Orion 180 Insurance Company | 17320 | IN | 2 | 9 | Homeowners, Commercial property (fire and allied lines) |
| Orion180 Select Insurance Company | 17438 | IN | 6 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Farm and crop +5 more |
| Progressive Paloverde Insurance Company | 44695 | IN | 1 | 0 | — |
| Progressive Southeastern Insurance Company | 38784 | IN | 9 | 0 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, Commercial package (BOP, CMP) +10 more |
| Property and Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford | 34690 | IN | 33 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +16 more |
| Property-Owners Insurance Company | 32905 | IN | 10 | 0 | General liability, Ocean marine, Commercial property (fire and allied lines) +2 more |
| Protective Insurance Company | 12416 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +13 more |
| Protective Specialty Insurance Company | 13149 | IN | 4 | 21 | Personal auto, Commercial auto, Inland marine +1 more |
| Safeco Insurance Company of Indiana | 11215 | IN | 32 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Crime (burglary and theft) +9 more |
| Sagamore Insurance Company | 40460 | IN | 32 | 1 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +13 more |
| Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina | 19259 | IN | 24 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +13 more |
| Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina | — | IN | 1 | 0 | — |
| Selective Insurance Company of the Southeast | 39926 | IN | 29 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +16 more |
| Twin City Fire Insurance Company (The) | 29459 | IN | 35 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +16 more |
| United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Company | 15288 | IN | 1 | 0 | — |
| UNIVERSAL FIRE \u0026 CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY | 32867 | IN | 31 | 0 | Aircraft and aviation, Personal auto, Equipment breakdown +11 more |
| Wellfleet Insurance Company | 32280 | IN | 33 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +13 more |
| West American Insurance Company | 44393 | IN | 34 | 0 | Personal auto, Equipment breakdown, Commercial auto +14 more |
Method and source
Indiana publishes its company list through a lookup that can't be read by a program, so the table above is built from the other states' lists, NAIC numbers, the U.S. Treasury's surety list and market share reports. A company missing here may still be licensed in Indiana; check the regulator's lookup. Lines are the regulator's licensed lines grouped into common names; a license to write a line doesn't mean a company sells it to every kind of customer. "Admitted" means licensed by the state and backed by its guaranty fund; "surplus lines" means eligible to take risks the admitted market declines, without rate or form approval and without guaranty fund protection.
Open to use. Cite "Alishahi Insurance insurance company directory" and link to this page. Download every company: CSV · JSON.
Need insurance in Indiana?
Someone will insure it. I find who.
Send what you need covered and what happened before. I match it to the companies that take it, down to the last-resort plan if it comes to that. I'm licensed in 48 states and Washington, DC and your request stays with my agency, not passed to another agent. In Florida and Washington, where my licenses are still being issued, a partner agency in your state helps in the meantime.
Not shopping yet?
Get a reminder before your renewal.
Tell me when your policy renews and I’ll email you about six weeks before, when it’s worth comparing. One email, no calls.