Modern two-story house with a pool
Directory · Wisconsin · Commercial auto

Who writes commercial auto in Wisconsin

Ranked by direct premium written in 2024 from the Wisconsin market share report (every company, not a top-N list).

312 companies wrote commercial auto in Wisconsin in 2024, $1.02B in direct premium. ACUITY, A Mutual Insurance Company led with 8.6%; the top five hold 33%. 392 companies are licensed for the line.

By Sam Alishahi, independent insurance broker · All lines in Wisconsin

Top 10 · NAIC table: Total Commercial Auto

The insurer groups that write the most commercial auto in Wisconsin

Top 10 insurer groups by direct premium written in 2025, from the NAIC's Market Share Reports for Property/Casualty Groups and Companies by State. A group is the parent and its insurance companies together; share is the group's part of the state total for the line; loss ratio is losses incurred over premium earned.

Commercial auto · Wisconsin

The companies

#CompanyNAICHome stateStatus herePremiumShare
1ACUITY, A Mutual Insurance Company14184WIAdmitted (licensed)$87.0M8.56%
2West Bend Insurance Company15350WIAdmitted (licensed)$72.5M7.13%
3Artisan and Truckers Casualty Company10194WIAdmitted (licensed)$69.9M6.87%
4Great West Casualty Company11371NEAdmitted (licensed)$51.6M5.07%
5SECURA Insurance Company22543WIAdmitted (licensed)$50.0M4.92%
6American Inter-Fidelity Exchange40088INAdmitted (licensed)$43.5M4.28%
7Rural Mutual Insurance Company15091WIAdmitted (licensed)$28.1M2.77%
8Auto-Owners Insurance Company18988MIAdmitted (licensed)$25.9M2.55%
9Zurich American Insurance Company16535NYAdmitted (licensed)$22.0M2.16%
10National Interstate Insurance Company32620OHAdmitted (licensed)$16.3M1.60%
11Integrity Insurance Company14303OHAdmitted (licensed)$16.0M1.58%
12Erie Insurance Exchange26271PAAdmitted (licensed)$15.4M1.51%
13Travelers Indemnity Company of Connecticut (The)25682CTAdmitted (licensed)$15.2M1.50%
14Cincinnati Insurance Company (The)10677OHAdmitted (licensed)$14.1M1.39%
15Middlesex Insurance Company23434WIAdmitted (licensed)$13.0M1.28%
16Western National Mutual Insurance Company15377MNAdmitted (licensed)$12.3M1.21%
17SOCIETY INSURANCE, a mutual company15261WIAdmitted (licensed)$12.2M1.20%
18EMPLOYERS MUTUAL CASUALTY COMPANY Employers Mutual Casualty Company)21415IAAdmitted (licensed)$11.8M1.16%
19New York Marine and General Insurance Company16608NYAdmitted (licensed)$11.4M1.12%
20Sentry Select Insurance Company21180WIAdmitted (licensed)$11.2M1.10%
21Travelers Property Casualty Company of America25674CTAdmitted (licensed)$11.2M1.10%
22Mobilitas General Insurance Company10675AZAdmitted (licensed)$11.1M1.10%
23Old Republic Insurance Company24147PAAdmitted (licensed)$11.1M1.09%
24Arch Insurance (UK) Limited11150MOAdmitted (licensed)$11.0M1.09%
25Federated Mutual Insurance Company13935MNAdmitted (licensed)$10.9M1.07%
26Pekin Insurance Company24228ILAdmitted (licensed)$9.2M0.91%
27National Indemnity Company20087NEAdmitted (licensed)$9.1M0.89%
28Wisconsin County Mutual Insurance Corporation26956WIAdmitted (licensed)$8.9M0.88%
29Midvale Indemnity Company27138WIAdmitted (licensed)$8.5M0.83%
30Frankenmuth Insurance Company13986MIAdmitted (licensed)$8.3M0.82%
31Travelers Indemnity Company (The)25658CTAdmitted (licensed)$8.0M0.79%
32Federated Reserve Insurance Company16024MNAdmitted (licensed)$7.7M0.76%
33Pioneer Specialty Insurance Company40312MNAdmitted (licensed)$7.6M0.74%
34Allmerica Financial Benefit Insurance Company41840MIAdmitted (licensed)$7.5M0.74%
35Greenwich Insurance Company22322DEAdmitted (licensed)$7.4M0.72%
36Ace American Insurance Company22667PAAdmitted (licensed)$6.8M0.67%
37League of Wisconsin Municipalities Mutual Insurance11527WIAdmitted (licensed)$6.7M0.66%
38Sentry Insurance Company24988WIAdmitted (licensed)$6.1M0.60%
39Selective Insurance Company of America12572NJAdmitted (licensed)$6.0M0.59%
40National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania19445PAAdmitted (licensed)$6.0M0.59%
41EMCASCO Insurance Company21407IAAdmitted (licensed)$6.0M0.59%
42Motorists Commercial Mutual Insurance Company13331OHAdmitted (licensed)$5.9M0.58%
43Owners Insurance Company32700OHAdmitted (licensed)$5.4M0.53%
44Northland Insurance Company24015CTAdmitted (licensed)$5.2M0.51%
45Federal Insurance Company20281INAdmitted (licensed)$5.2M0.51%
46Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company18058PAAdmitted (licensed)$5.1M0.50%
47State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company25178ILAdmitted (licensed)$4.9M0.48%
48Partners Mutual Insurance Company13439WIAdmitted (licensed)$4.7M0.46%
49UNITED FIRE \u0026 CASUALTY COMPANY13021IAAdmitted (licensed)$4.6M0.45%
50Hartford Fire Insurance Company19682CTAdmitted (licensed)$4.4M0.43%
51Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company23035WIAdmitted (licensed)$4.3M0.43%
52Cities and Villages Mutual Insurance Company24830WIAdmitted (licensed)$4.0M0.39%
53Charter Oak Fire Insurance Company, (The)25615CTAdmitted (licensed)$3.6M0.36%
54Hastings Insurance Company14176MIAdmitted (licensed)$3.5M0.35%
55Community Insurance Corporation11250WIAdmitted (licensed)$3.5M0.34%
56Canal Insurance Company10464SCAdmitted (licensed)$3.4M0.34%
57Ace Property and Casualty Insurance Company20699PAAdmitted (licensed)$3.4M0.34%
58Continental Casualty Company20443ILAdmitted (licensed)$3.4M0.33%
59Integrity Property and Casualty Insurance Company12986OHAdmitted (licensed)$3.4M0.33%
60National Specialty Insurance Company22608TXAdmitted (licensed)$3.3M0.33%
61Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Insurance Company20044NEAdmitted (licensed)$3.3M0.33%
62Empire Fire and Marine Insurance Company21326ILAdmitted (licensed)$3.2M0.31%
63IMT Insurance Company14257IAAdmitted (licensed)$3.2M0.31%
64Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company, SI14117IAAdmitted (licensed)$3.1M0.31%
65Transit Mutual Insurance Corporation of Wisconsin21270WIAdmitted (licensed)$3.1M0.30%
66Nationwide Agribusiness Insurance Company28223IAAdmitted (licensed)$3.0M0.29%
67Travelers Indemnity Company of America (The)25666CTAdmitted (licensed)$2.9M0.28%
68RLI Insurance Company13056ILAdmitted (licensed)$2.8M0.28%
69Falls Lake National Insurance Company31925OHAdmitted (licensed)$2.8M0.28%
70Integon National Insurance Company29742ILAdmitted (licensed)$2.8M0.27%
71United States Fire Insurance Company21113DEAdmitted (licensed)$2.7M0.26%
72National Fire Insurance Company of Hartford20478ILAdmitted (licensed)$2.6M0.26%
73Western National Assurance Company24465MNAdmitted (licensed)$2.4M0.24%
74Triangle Insurance Company, Inc.28535OKAdmitted (licensed)$2.3M0.23%
75First Chicago Insurance Company13587ILAdmitted (licensed)$2.2M0.22%
76Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina19259INAdmitted (licensed)$2.2M0.22%
77Valley Forge Insurance Company20508PAAdmitted (licensed)$2.2M0.21%
78Berkley Casualty Company15911IAAdmitted (licensed)$2.2M0.21%
79Continental Insurance Company, (The)35289PAAdmitted (licensed)$2.1M0.21%
80Westfield Insurance Company24112OHAdmitted (licensed)$2.1M0.21%
81Great American Assurance Company26344OHAdmitted (licensed)$2.0M0.20%
82Transportation Insurance Company20494ILAdmitted (licensed)$2.0M0.20%
83Incline Casualty Company11090TXAdmitted (licensed)$2.0M0.19%
84Donegal Mutual Insurance Company13692PAAdmitted (licensed)$2.0M0.19%
85NATIONAL LIABILITY \u0026 FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY20052CTAdmitted (licensed)$1.9M0.19%
86Atlantic States Insurance Company22586PAAdmitted (licensed)$1.8M0.18%
87STARR INDEMNITY \u0026 LIABILITY COMPANY38318TXAdmitted (licensed)$1.8M0.18%
88Carolina Casualty Insurance Company10510IAAdmitted (licensed)$1.8M0.18%
89Selective Insurance Company of the Southeast39926INAdmitted (licensed)$1.7M0.17%
90American Casualty Company of Reading, Pennsylvania20427PAAdmitted (licensed)$1.7M0.17%
91Motors Insurance Corporation22012MIAdmitted (licensed)$1.7M0.17%
92Cincinnati Indemnity Company (The)23280OHAdmitted (licensed)$1.7M0.16%
93Midwest Family Mutual Insurance Company23574IAAdmitted (licensed)$1.6M0.16%
94Atlantic Specialty Insurance Company27154NYAdmitted (licensed)$1.6M0.16%
95Rockford Mutual Insurance Company27065ILAdmitted (licensed)$1.5M0.15%
96Hudson Insurance Company25054DEAdmitted (licensed)$1.5M0.15%
97Everest National Insurance Company10120DEAdmitted (licensed)$1.5M0.14%
98Navigators Insurance Company42307NYAdmitted (licensed)$1.5M0.14%
99Great Northern Insurance Company20303INAdmitted (licensed)$1.4M0.14%
100Acadia Insurance Company31325IAAdmitted (licensed)$1.4M0.13%
101Church Mutual Insurance Company, S. I.18767WIAdmitted (licensed)$1.3M0.13%
102State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company25135OHAdmitted (licensed)$1.3M0.13%
103St. Paul Protective Insurance Company19224CTAdmitted (licensed)$1.3M0.13%
104Harleysville Insurance Company23582OHAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.12%
105Lancer Insurance Company26077ILAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.12%
106Protective Insurance Company12416INAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.12%
107Wesco Insurance Company25011DEAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.12%
108Safety National Casualty Corporation15105MOAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.12%
109Integrity Select Insurance Company10288OHAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.11%
110Everspan Insurance Company24961AZAdmitted (licensed)$1.2M0.11%
111Pennsylvania Lumbermen's Mutual Insurance Company14974PAAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
112Addison Insurance Company10324IAAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
113Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company10831WIAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
114Trumbull Insurance Company27120CTAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
115Vanliner Insurance Company21172OHAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
116American Guarantee and Liability Insurance Company26247NYAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
117Ohio Security Insurance Company24082NHAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.11%
118Fremont Insurance Company13994MIAdmitted (licensed)$1.1M0.10%
119Federated Service Insurance Company28304MNAdmitted (licensed)$1.0M0.10%
120Continental Western Insurance Company10804IAAdmitted (licensed)$997,2930.10%
121Union Insurance Company25844IAAdmitted (licensed)$996,8770.10%
122American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.19275WIAdmitted (licensed)$993,8950.10%
123Williamsburg National Insurance Company25780MIAdmitted (licensed)$979,6650.10%
124Wisconsin Municipal Mutual Insurance Company27880WIAdmitted (licensed)$953,9990.09%
125Germantown Mutual Insurance Company14036WIAdmitted (licensed)$937,2620.09%
126St. Paul Mercury Insurance Company24791CTAdmitted (licensed)$911,7000.09%
127Berkshire Hathaway Direct Insurance Company10391NEAdmitted (licensed)$906,3100.09%
128Travelers Casualty Insurance Company of America19046CTAdmitted (licensed)$897,1450.09%
129Berkley National Insurance Company38911IAAdmitted (licensed)$896,7450.09%
130GEICO Marine Insurance Company37923NEAdmitted (licensed)$867,2500.09%
131Berkley Regional Insurance Company29580IAAdmitted (licensed)$865,9830.09%
132State Farm Fire and Casualty Company25143ILAdmitted (licensed)$860,6950.08%
133Riverport Insurance Company36684IAAdmitted (licensed)$803,2730.08%
134GEICO General Insurance Company35882NEAdmitted (licensed)$799,5840.08%
135Union Insurance Company of Providence21423IAAdmitted (licensed)$765,6810.08%
136Allied Property and Casualty Insurance Company42579IAAdmitted (licensed)$745,9910.07%
137Obsidian Insurance Company35602OHAdmitted (licensed)$737,9810.07%
138New South Insurance Company12130ILAdmitted (licensed)$734,4870.07%
139Fire Insurance Exchange Fire Underwriters Association21660CAAdmitted (licensed)$711,8350.07%
140Cincinnati Casualty Company (The)28665OHAdmitted (licensed)$702,1980.07%
141Markel Insurance Company38970ILAdmitted (licensed)$683,3050.07%
142AmGUARD Insurance Company42390NEAdmitted (licensed)$671,8240.07%
143North River Insurance Company (The)21105NJAdmitted (licensed)$660,4500.06%
144Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company27022WIAdmitted (licensed)$648,2170.06%
145COUNTRY Mutual Insurance Company20990ILAdmitted (licensed)$640,1960.06%
146Amerisure Mutual Insurance Company23396MIAdmitted (licensed)$618,6070.06%
147Great Divide Insurance Company25224NDAdmitted (licensed)$610,8860.06%
148Tokio Marine America Insurance Company10945NYAdmitted (licensed)$604,5260.06%
149Forge Insurance Company13293DCAdmitted (licensed)$597,8250.06%
150Sutton National Insurance Company25798OKAdmitted (licensed)$587,8420.06%
151Federated Rural Electric Insurance Exchange11118KSAdmitted (licensed)$586,0520.06%
152Nutmeg Insurance Company39608CTAdmitted (licensed)$579,5290.06%
153Indemnity Insurance Company of North America43575PAAdmitted (licensed)$556,4210.05%
154MS Transverse Insurance Company21075TXAdmitted (licensed)$549,2920.05%
155Everest Denali Insurance Company16044DEAdmitted (licensed)$536,8880.05%
156Depositors Insurance Company42587IAAdmitted (licensed)$498,3130.05%
157Trisura Insurance Company22225OKAdmitted (licensed)$491,7220.05%
158Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company10723OHAdmitted (licensed)$491,0520.05%
159Allstate Insurance Company19232ILAdmitted (licensed)$486,1470.05%
160Great American Insurance Company16691OHAdmitted (licensed)$473,0170.05%
161Sompo America Insurance Company11126NYAdmitted (licensed)$456,7800.04%
162GuideOne Insurance Company15032IAAdmitted (licensed)$456,0240.04%
163Star Insurance Company18023MIAdmitted (licensed)$456,0160.04%
164Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company22357CTAdmitted (licensed)$444,7490.04%
165Motorists Mutual Insurance Company14621OHAdmitted (licensed)$440,4030.04%
166CRUM \u0026 FORSTER INDEMNITY COMPANY31348DEAdmitted (licensed)$435,6870.04%
167American Family Home Insurance Company23450FLAdmitted (licensed)$415,1350.04%
168North Pointe Insurance Company27740PAAdmitted (licensed)$412,6600.04%
169Zurich American Insurance Company of Illinois27855ILAdmitted (licensed)$411,7340.04%
170TransGuard Insurance Company of America, Inc.28886ILAdmitted (licensed)$406,3460.04%
171Imperium Insurance Company35408TXAdmitted (licensed)$400,1460.04%
172St. Paul Guardian Insurance Company24775CTAdmitted (licensed)$389,3920.04%
173Liberty Mutual Insurance Company23043MAAdmitted (licensed)$383,5640.04%
174Benchmark Insurance Company41394KSAdmitted (licensed)$380,5300.04%
175Cumis Insurance Society Incorporated10847IAAdmitted (licensed)$364,9070.04%
176Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company13528INAdmitted (licensed)$364,2730.04%
177BITCO General Insurance Corporation20095IAAdmitted (licensed)$362,9760.04%
178First Liberty Insurance Corporation (The)33588ILAdmitted (licensed)$362,0050.04%
179Intrepid Insurance Company10749IAAdmitted (licensed)$360,9340.04%
180Manufacturers Alliance Insurance Company36897PAAdmitted (licensed)$359,9620.04%
181L M Insurance Corporation33600ILAdmitted (licensed)$352,0270.03%
182Hanover Insurance Company (The)22292NHAdmitted (licensed)$345,8520.03%
183STATE AUTO PROPERTY \u0026 CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY25127IAAdmitted (licensed)$345,5310.03%
184Accredited Surety and Casualty Company, Inc.26379FLAdmitted (licensed)$339,4770.03%
185Allied World Specialty Insurance Company16624DEAdmitted (licensed)$320,5590.03%
186Phoenix Insurance Company, (The)25623CTAdmitted (licensed)$318,1770.03%
187AXIS Insurance Company37273ILAdmitted (licensed)$284,1780.03%
188Amerisure Insurance Company19488MIAdmitted (licensed)$269,2760.03%
189Spinnaker Insurance Company24376ILAdmitted (licensed)$260,5670.03%
190Fidelity and Guaranty Insurance Company35386IAAdmitted (licensed)$258,9200.03%
191American Modern Home Insurance Company23469OHAdmitted (licensed)$257,2880.03%
192First Guard Insurance Company10676AZAdmitted (licensed)$255,7550.03%
193Austin Mutual Insurance Company13412FLAdmitted (licensed)$251,4950.02%
194Westfield National Insurance Company24120OHAdmitted (licensed)$247,1620.02%
195Key Risk Insurance Company10885IAAdmitted (licensed)$245,8540.02%
196Liberty Mutual Insurance Company42404ILAdmitted (licensed)$244,3680.02%
197OCCIDENTAL FIRE \u0026 CASUALTY COMPANY OF NORTH CAROLINA23248NCAdmitted (licensed)$239,6290.02%
198North Star Mutual Insurance Company14850MNAdmitted (licensed)$230,7600.02%
199American Zurich Insurance Company40142ILAdmitted (licensed)$226,7350.02%
200Farmington Casualty Company41483CTAdmitted (licensed)$213,3570.02%
201Travelers Casualty Company of Connecticut36170CTAdmitted (licensed)$203,5350.02%
202Praetorian Insurance Company37257PAAdmitted (licensed)$202,6800.02%
203Massachusetts Bay Insurance Company22306NHAdmitted (licensed)$202,3470.02%
204Truck Insurance Exchange21709CAAdmitted (licensed)$201,1920.02%
205American National Property and Casualty Company28401NEAdmitted (licensed)$199,1220.02%
206American Southern Home Insurance Company41998FLAdmitted (licensed)$198,4980.02%
207Harleysville Worcester Insurance Company26182OHAdmitted (licensed)$193,4330.02%
208Preferred Professional Insurance Company36234NEAdmitted (licensed)$190,7210.02%
209QBE Insurance (Europe) Limited39217PAAdmitted (licensed)$187,8560.02%
210American Automobile Insurance Company21849MOAdmitted (licensed)$186,9760.02%
211Sentinel Insurance Company, Limited11000CTAdmitted (licensed)$183,4370.02%
212American Select Insurance Company19992OHAdmitted (licensed)$180,6920.02%
213Chiron Insurance Company16356IAAdmitted (licensed)$178,6000.02%
214American Fire and Casualty Company24066NHAdmitted (licensed)$171,3450.02%
215AmTrust Insurance Company15954DEAdmitted (licensed)$166,6500.02%
216Penn Millers Insurance Company14982PAAdmitted (licensed)$163,1730.02%
217Nova Casualty Company42552NYAdmitted (licensed)$162,4190.02%
218State National Insurance Company, Inc.12831TXAdmitted (licensed)$156,5980.02%
219Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance USA Inc.22551NYAdmitted (licensed)$155,1190.02%
220Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company30104CTAdmitted (licensed)$153,8960.02%
221Great Plains Casualty, Inc.12982IAAdmitted (licensed)$153,3340.02%
222New Hampshire Insurance Company23841ILAdmitted (licensed)$151,3680.01%
223Farmers Insurance Exchange21652CAAdmitted (licensed)$141,7290.01%
224General Insurance Company of America24732NHAdmitted (licensed)$139,2690.01%
225Standard Fire Insurance Company (The)19070CTAdmitted (licensed)$138,1440.01%
226Grinnell Compass, Inc.15831IAAdmitted (licensed)$135,8320.01%
227StarStone National Insurance Company25496DEAdmitted (licensed)$133,8310.01%
228Clear Blue Insurance Company28860TXAdmitted (licensed)$130,9240.01%
229Granite State Insurance Company23809ILAdmitted (licensed)$130,4650.01%
230Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company of America20362NYAdmitted (licensed)$128,8470.01%
231Ohio Casualty Insurance Company (The)24074NHAdmitted (licensed)$126,5870.01%
232Rural Trust Insurance Company11134TXAdmitted (licensed)$118,8490.01%
233All America Insurance Company20222OHAdmitted (licensed)$113,5380.01%
234Wilshire Insurance Company13234NCAdmitted (licensed)$113,4260.01%
235Hartford Casualty Insurance Company29424INAdmitted (licensed)$111,5310.01%
236Harco National Insurance Company26433ILAdmitted (licensed)$108,2180.01%
237American Road Insurance Company (The)19631MIAdmitted (licensed)$107,0240.01%
238Mid-Century Insurance Company21687CAAdmitted (licensed)$106,8930.01%
239StarNet Insurance Company40045IAAdmitted (licensed)$104,1460.01%
240Everest Premier Insurance Company16045DEAdmitted (licensed)$96,0260.01%
241Grinnell Select Insurance Company16144IAAdmitted (licensed)$95,9560.01%
242Vantapro Specialty Insurance Company44768ARAdmitted (licensed)$94,0910.01%
243West American Insurance Company44393INAdmitted (licensed)$92,3930.01%
244National Casualty Company11991OHAdmitted (licensed)$90,8590.01%
245Argonaut-Midwest Insurance Company19828NEAdmitted (licensed)$86,3730.01%
246Milford Casualty Insurance Company26662DEAdmitted (licensed)$82,3080.01%
247Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest37478INAdmitted (licensed)$81,3550.01%
248XL Insurance America, Inc.24554DEAdmitted (licensed)$78,7680.01%
249Allstate Indemnity Company19240ILAdmitted (licensed)$73,5090.01%
250American Reliable Insurance Company19615AZAdmitted (licensed)$71,6560.01%
251Old Guard Insurance Company17558OHAdmitted (licensed)$69,3210.01%
252Nationwide Insurance Company of America25453OHAdmitted (licensed)$58,1520.01%
253Municipal Property Insurance Company15779WIAdmitted (licensed)$52,0630.01%
254Property and Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford34690INAdmitted (licensed)$51,1840.01%
255Swiss Re Corporate Solutions Elite Insurance Corporation29700MOAdmitted (licensed)$48,7190.00%
256Intrepid Casualty Company17182IAAdmitted (licensed)$47,6040.00%
257Ohio Farmers Insurance Company24104OHAdmitted (licensed)$47,0740.00%
258Peninsula Insurance Company (The)14958MDAdmitted (licensed)$46,5130.00%
259Citizens Insurance Company of America31534MIAdmitted (licensed)$45,9300.00%
260XL Specialty Insurance Company37885DEAdmitted (licensed)$45,5370.00%
261Westfield Champion Insurance Company16447OHAdmitted (licensed)$44,4880.00%
262Knightbrook Insurance Company13722DEAdmitted (licensed)$43,7650.00%
263Great American Insurance Company of New York22136NYAdmitted (licensed)$42,3700.00%
264Arch Property Casualty Insurance Company10946MOAdmitted (licensed)$41,9290.00%
265Phenix Mutual Fire Insurance Company23175OHAdmitted (licensed)$41,5290.00%
266Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania (The)19429ILAdmitted (licensed)$39,4600.00%
267Accelerant National Insurance Company10220ARAdmitted (licensed)$37,9420.00%
268Swiss Re Corporate Solutions America Insurance Corporation29874MOAdmitted (licensed)$37,7620.00%
269Nationwide General Insurance Company23760OHAdmitted (licensed)$32,9690.00%
270Chubb National Insurance Company10052INAdmitted (licensed)$32,4690.00%
271Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Company22276NEAdmitted (licensed)$32,3230.00%
272Great American Alliance Insurance Company26832OHAdmitted (licensed)$29,7360.00%
273SECURA Supreme Insurance Company10239WIAdmitted (licensed)$27,5920.00%
274HDI Global Insurance Company41343ILAdmitted (licensed)$26,0590.00%
275American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida10111FLAdmitted (licensed)$25,5400.00%
276Stonington Insurance Company10340PAAdmitted (licensed)$25,1680.00%
277Wadena Insurance Company12528IAAdmitted (licensed)$23,1530.00%
278Amerisure Partners Insurance Company11050MIAdmitted (licensed)$21,4360.00%
279Rock Ridge Insurance Company11089TXAdmitted (licensed)$21,1470.00%
280Westfield Premier Insurance Company16450OHAdmitted (licensed)$21,0020.00%
281Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company23787OHAdmitted (licensed)$19,5880.00%
282Twin City Fire Insurance Company (The)29459INAdmitted (licensed)$17,9930.00%
283Westfield Superior Insurance Company16449OHAdmitted (licensed)$16,4340.00%
284Ansur America Insurance Company10984MIAdmitted (licensed)$16,0550.00%
285Gateway Insurance Company28339ILAdmitted (licensed)$15,8410.00%
286Harleysville Preferred Insurance Company35696OHAdmitted (licensed)$13,1510.00%
287Tri-State Insurance Company of Minnesota31003IAAdmitted (licensed)$11,8310.00%
288Westfield Touchstone Insurance Company16448OHAdmitted (licensed)$11,7400.00%
289National Fire & Casualty Company41068ILAdmitted (licensed)$10,8370.00%
290Employers Insurance Company of Wausau21458WIAdmitted (licensed)$9,8180.00%
291RepWest Insurance Company31089AZAdmitted (licensed)$9,7420.00%
292Fireman's Fund Insurance Company21873ILAdmitted (licensed)$8,5520.00%
293Contractors Bonding and Insurance Company37206ILAdmitted (licensed)$6,1200.00%
294Illinois National Insurance Company23817ILAdmitted (licensed)$5,2030.00%
295Ace Fire Underwriters Insurance Company20702PAAdmitted (licensed)$4,8570.00%
296Technology Insurance Company, Inc.42376DEAdmitted (licensed)$3,7480.00%
297Argonaut Insurance Company19801NEAdmitted (licensed)$3,6380.00%
298CM Select Insurance Company16203COAdmitted (licensed)$3,2130.00%
299American Standard Insurance Company of Wisconsin19283WIAdmitted (licensed)$2,9710.00%
300Republic-Franklin Insurance Company12475OHAdmitted (licensed)$2,9020.00%
301Pacific Indemnity Company20346DEAdmitted (licensed)$2,4120.00%
302American Southern Insurance Company10235KSAdmitted (licensed)$1,6640.00%
303Utica Mutual Insurance Company25976NYAdmitted (licensed)$1,5000.00%
304Pennsylvania Manufacturers Indemnity Company41424PAAdmitted (licensed)$1,4600.00%
305Mid-Continent Casualty Company23418OHAdmitted (licensed)$1,3580.00%
306Allied Insurance Company of America10127OHAdmitted (licensed)$1,2790.00%
307Strathmore Insurance Company11024NYAdmitted (licensed)$6790.00%
308Mid-Continent Assurance Company15380OHAdmitted (licensed)$2520.00%
309Chubb Indemnity Insurance Company12777NYAdmitted (licensed)$2000.00%
310AMCO Insurance Company19100IAAdmitted (licensed)$1960.00%
311American Home Assurance Company19380NYAdmitted (licensed)$840.00%
312Seneca Insurance Company Incorporated10936NYAdmitted (licensed)$70.00%
Turned down?

Last resort for commercial auto in Wisconsin

Last resortLinesWhereHow to get in
Auto assigned-risk planspersonal auto, commercial autoall states (AIPSO runs CA CAARP and Low Cost Auto plus AK, AZ, CO, ID, MT, NV, NM, OR, UT, WA, WY; CAIP handles commercial auto)California CAARP: any CA fire and casualty licensee can get certified (application and license copy to [email protected]) Elsewhere the state's Automobile Insurance Plan administered by AIPSO (aipso.com), through any licensed agent.Source
Surplus lines and Lloyd's open marketallall states, under each state's diligent-search rulesThrough surplus lines wholesalers; commercial property and liability have no guaranteed plan, so this is their last stepSource

Method and source

Source: the Wisconsin insurance regulator company list, read 2026-10-18. Admitted = union of two OCI 2025 Wisconsin Insurance Report documents joined by normalized name: Table E market share (every insurer with 2025 WI premium, all 48 lines incl. life/annuity/A&H; gives NAIC code + lines) and the Directory of Licensed Insurers as of 12/31/2025 (gives domicile, company type, year commenced in WI; no NAIC; https://oci.wi.gov/Documents/AboutOCI/2025_WIR_Directory.pdf). Join stats: {'exact': 1249, 'fuzzy': 3, 'unmatched_xlsx': 2, 'directory_rows': 2281, 'table_e_naic': 1254, 'directory_unmatched': 1029}. Rows with naic '' are directory-only (licensed but no 2025 WI premium or name not matched); rows with type '' are Table E only (name not matched to the directory). Type codes: AR=Accredited Reinsurer; CR=Certified Reinsurer; RJR=Reciprocal Jurisdiction Reinsurer; DSL=Domestic Surplus Line; FR=Fraternal Benefit Society; CC=Continuing Care Organization; CMO=Care Management Organization; HMO=Health Maintenance Organization; IRO=Independent Review Organization; LAH=Life and Accident and Health Company; LSP=Life Settlement Provider; RRG=Risk Retention Group; LSHO=Limited Service Health Organization; MC=Motor Club Plan; SCP=Service Contract Provider; PC=Property and Casualty Company; TI=Title Company; TM=Town Mutual of Wisconsin; VPP=Vehicle Protection Plan; WP=Warranty Plan. Filter P&C with type in {PC, RRG, DSL, TM, TI} or lines among the P&C lines (Table E sheets 34-48: FIRE, FARMOWNERS MULTIPLE PERIL, HOMEOWNERS MULTIPLE PERIL, COMMERCIAL MULTIPLE PERIL, MEDICAL MALPRACTICE, WORKERS COMPENSATION, EXCESS WORKERS COMPENSATION, OTHER LIABILITY, PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO, COMMERCIAL AUTO, FIDELITY, SURETY, CREDIT, MORTGAGE GUARANTY, TITLE; sheet 33 STOP LOSS/EXCESS LOSS; line strings are the sheet titles, which differ slightly from the TOC). Directory also lists non-insurers (SCP, WP, VPP, MC, LSP, IRO, CC, CMO) and reinsurers (AR, CR, RJR); foreign domiciles are blanked. 'since' = year commenced business in WI. Wisconsin publishes no eligible surplus lines list (NRRA home-state rule; NAIC IID list for aliens), so surplus_lines is empty. "Premium" is direct premium written in the state for the year shown; "share" is that company's part of the state total for the line. A company can be licensed for a line and write none of it, and a surplus lines insurer can write a line without a state license for it.

Open to use. Cite "Alishahi Insurance insurance company directory" and link here. CSV · JSON.

Need commercial auto in Wisconsin?

Someone will insure it. I find who.

Send what you need covered and what happened before. I match it to the companies that take it, down to the last-resort plan if it comes to that. I'm licensed in 48 states and Washington, DC and your request stays with my agency, not passed to another agent. In Florida and Washington, where my licenses are still being issued, a partner agency in your state helps in the meantime.

Not shopping yet?

Get a reminder before your renewal.

Tell me when your policy renews and I’ll email you about six weeks before, when it’s worth comparing. One email, no calls.